CO129-058 - Sir Bowring - 1856 [8-10] — Page 336

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Lo Nr 25

Victoria, 20th September 1885

In response to your letter of yesterday, I express my regret that mine of that date failed to put you in possession of any information. My letter and the Correspondence laid before you are contained herein.

If, from the perusal of Clause 8 of 1856, you think yourself at liberty to ask me such questions, it is evident to me that we differ considerably as to the meanings of many words in the English language, and that therefore questions propounded by you would only produce a misunderstanding.

I have the honour to be, Sir,

Your Most Obedient Servant,

(Signed) William Comer

Acting Surveyor General.

20th September 1885

The Hon. W. H. Marsh

Colonial Secretary

Hall, 11th September 1868

I have the honour to request that you will lay the accompanying Correspondence before the Governor.

I require this for the purpose of being embodied in a Memorial of this transaction which I am preparing for the Secretary of State, and I now address myself with all respect to His Excellency, requesting that he will either be pleased to command that the information be given to me, or leave to justify the refusal to grant it, and take upon himself the whole responsibility of that refusal.

I beg to state that materials worth several hundred dollars, which were adjudged to be a nuisance and ordered to be carried away, were actually carried away by the Surveyor General and his gang of convicts, while the natural charges of abating the nuisance did not amount to twenty dollars. I ask for the purpose of laying my complaint before the Secretary of State, and the Supreme Court, and the Imperial Parliament: What became of the surplus?

I have been told that my enquiry is considered an eccentric one.

I again and finally ask, with all respect, that a better answer is prepared to justify that response, either directly or by refusing to interfere with it.

I have the honour to be, Sir,

Your Obedient Servant,

(Signed) A. Nielson

Copy

Correspondence between the Surveyor General and Engineer New Extension between John Kennish;

My letters in address are numbered 14, the Surveyor General's replies are 19 to 21.

The information which I have applied for, I require.

Colonial Secretary's Office, Victoria, Hong Kong, 2nd September 1856

I have the honour to acknowledge your letter, and am directed to reply that the questions involved in it imply a recrimination against the acting Surveyor General.

Edit History

2026-05-18 05:26:47 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Lo Nr 25 Victoria, 20th September 1885 In response to your letter of yesterday, I express my regret that mine of that date failed to put you in possession of any information. My letter and the Correspondence laid before you are contained herein. If, from the perusal of Clause 8 of 1856, you think yourself at liberty to ask me such questions, it is evident to me that we differ considerably as to the meanings of many words in the English language, and that therefore questions propounded by you would only produce a misunderstanding. I have the honour to be, Sir, Your Most Obedient Servant, (Signed) William Comer Acting Surveyor General. 20th September 1885 The Hon. W. H. Marsh Colonial Secretary Hall, 11th September 1868 I have the honour to request that you will lay the accompanying Correspondence before the Governor. I require this for the purpose of being embodied in a Memorial of this transaction which I am preparing for the Secretary of State, and I now address myself with all respect to His Excellency, requesting that he will either be pleased to command that the information be given to me, or leave to justify the refusal to grant it, and take upon himself the whole responsibility of that refusal. I beg to state that materials worth several hundred dollars, which were adjudged to be a nuisance and ordered to be carried away, were actually carried away by the Surveyor General and his gang of convicts, while the natural charges of abating the nuisance did not amount to twenty dollars. I ask for the purpose of laying my complaint before the Secretary of State, and the Supreme Court, and the Imperial Parliament: What became of the surplus? I have been told that my enquiry is considered an eccentric one. I again and finally ask, with all respect, that a better answer is prepared to justify that response, either directly or by refusing to interfere with it. I have the honour to be, Sir, Your Obedient Servant, (Signed) A. Nielson Copy Correspondence between the Surveyor General and Engineer New Extension between John Kennish; My letters in address are numbered 14, the Surveyor General's replies are 19 to 21. The information which I have applied for, I require. Colonial Secretary's Office, Victoria, Hong Kong, 2nd September 1856 I have the honour to acknowledge your letter, and am directed to reply that the questions involved in it imply a recrimination against the acting Surveyor General.
Baseline (Original)
22 Copy Lo Nr 25 In Smagny Lennal Offic Victoria, 20th September 1885 d anomers to your litter of gesterday, a expres my resred that mime of that date failed to put you in persession, of sny outenting, My to and the Correspotice lotarien var for as Innote he fore. cous as are Contained non If from the pause of trivance 8 of 1856, qui think yourself past food in acting me to me litat we such questions Jouer lithis, it is bordent to me that we differ Considerably a to the meanings of many The English language, and that there for quiations propounded by you me muld only produce a Trepound this and by mords. I have the hover tale, Fir AR. Automley Copy & the I and answered misundersta Serstanding. Your Most Obedient Servant- (Signed) Wellium Comper Acting Surveyor General. 20th The Abb. 2. Meer Ley Colonial Lerstary Hall 11.3 Men Haughing 2006 September 1868 I have the house & request that you will lay the Allermpanying Correspond denar betwnge the dence. 334 requins for the perspace of being combodiedian a Memorial of this transaction which I am preparing for the Lienetary of state, and. I now address myelf with all respect to this Excelline, requesting that he will either ho praend to command this an information by the be given to one, or lee to justify the rating Porvage, Loveral in his refusal to quin it, and take upon himself the whole responsibility of that refusal. مجھے give Iall y. that inotereals which lost moorening hundred dollar Nuisance abundan is, mere Carried away by the Surga yor General and his gang of Convicts, while the natural Charges of abating the adjudged, did not amount the the ty Nollars & ask for the purpose of laying my oberly before the Deentary of State, and the Supria and the Imperial Parliament: What- became of the sur plon ? and am told, that my enquiry " ecentric one. Pase Aver is Zagain and finally ask, with all respect, a better Nis Groetheney is prepared to quctify that answer, either directly. er by refusing to interfere with it. I have the hover to be, sir, Leneral Copy Gfy M181. between the Surveyor and Engels lehorn New Exalteway ben John Kenning; My letters in addrew are numbered 1/4, _ the Causeyor Generate in reply 19 to 21. The information which Thave this this in vain. applied for, Irequire Your Brest obedient Servant. (Reyned) A. Niedson Colonial proretary's office Victoria, Houghing, 2nd September 1856 I have the hover to acknowledge yo we fitter, Niss chetant, and an directed to reply, that the question suvolaed in it simplies are recusation against the loting of testing furveyor
2026-05-18 05:26:47 · Baseline
View content

22

Copy

Lo

Nr 25

In

Smagny Lennal Offic

Victoria, 20th September 1885

d

anomers to your litter of gesterday, a expres my resred that mime of that date failed to put you in persession, of sny outenting, My to and the Correspotice lotarien var for as Innote he fore.

cous as are Contained non

If from the pause of trivance 8 of 1856, qui think yourself past food in acting me to me litat we such questions Jouer lithis, it is bordent to me that we differ Considerably a to the meanings of many

The English language, and that there for quiations propounded by you

me muld only produce a Trepound this and

by

mords.

I have the hover tale, Fir

AR. Automley

Copy & the I

and answered misundersta

Serstanding.

Your Most Obedient Servant- (Signed) Wellium Comper

Acting Surveyor General.

20th

The Abb. 2. Meer Ley

Colonial Lerstary

Hall 11.3 Men Haughing 2006 September 1868

I have the house & request that you will lay the

Allermpanying Correspond

denar betwnge the

dence.

334

requins for the perspace of being combodiedian a Memorial of this transaction which I am preparing for the Lienetary of state, and. I now address myelf with all respect to this Excelline, requesting that he will either ho praend to command this an information by the be given to one, or lee to justify the rating Porvage, Loveral in his refusal to quin it, and take upon himself the whole responsibility of that refusal.

مجھے

give

Iall y. that inotereals which lost moorening hundred

dollar

Nuisance abundan

is, mere Carried away by the Surga yor General and his gang of Convicts, while the natural Charges of abating the adjudged, did not amount the the ty Nollars & ask for the purpose of laying my

oberly before the Deentary of State, and the Supria

and the Imperial Parliament: What- became of the sur plon ? and am told, that my enquiry

"

ecentric one.

Pase Aver

is

Zagain and finally ask, with all respect, a better Nis Groetheney is prepared to quctify that answer, either directly. er by refusing to interfere with it.

I have the hover to be, sir,

Leneral

Copy

Gfy M181.

between the Surveyor and Engels lehorn New Exalteway ben John Kenning;

My letters in addrew are numbered 1/4, _ the Causeyor

Generate in reply 19 to 21.

The

information which Thave this

this in vain.

applied for, Irequire

Your Brest obedient Servant. (Reyned) A. Niedson

Colonial proretary's office Victoria, Houghing, 2nd September 1856

I have the hover to acknowledge yo we fitter, Niss chetant, and an directed to reply, that the question suvolaed in it simplies are recusation against the loting

of

testing

furveyor

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.